Global Embedding of Analytic Branes into
Einstein MD Bulk Cosmology: Wormholes
Nikolaos I. Katzourakis
*
*
Address: Troias 6, 18541, Kaminia, Pireaus, Greece University of Athens, Department of Mathematics e-mail: nkatzourakis@math.uoa.gr
Abstract
In a series of recent papers [26] , [27] , [28] we have shown that:
(I) any
-dimensional analytic semi-Riemannian manifold
has a global isometric analytic embedding into an Einstein manifold
of dimension
,
(
).
(II) There exists an Einstein global embedding space
, admitting unsmoothable differential-topological singularities (
points or extended
spatial ”anomalies”) living into the complement
. They were expounded as wormholes. The topologies of such
&
's have been studied, showing that Homotopy & Homology split in both cases.
(III) Any finite-many analytic semi-Riemannian manifolds
, ...,
have all a global isometric analytic embedding into an
-Einstein Bulk
as disjoint submanifolds, while both
&
split. The optimum dimensionality corresponds to
.
In this paper we continue extending further these results on Cosmological Brane embeddings:
There exists an Einstein global embedding space
, admitting unsmoothable differential-topological singularities (
points or extended
spatial ”anomalies”) living into the complement
.
We further calculate the (reduced) Homology
of
which proves to split in every dimension, without dependence on any
,
.
Keywords: Spacetime Embedding, Einstein space, Campbell-Magaard Theorem, Homology; Brane-World, MD Gravity, Brane Cosmology MSC Subject Classification
: Primary 53C20, 53C25, 32C09, 53Cxx; Secondary 83C75, 83C55, 83E15, 83F05.
Global Embedding of Analytic Branes in MD
Einstein Bulk Introduction The concept of the spacetime manifold as a model of the large scale structure of the Universe is a result of evolution in both physical & mathematical attitudes.
Once we used to think of Euclidean flat
-space as the case of interest in mathematics, constituting in the same time the model of the Newtonian space-time.
In the first half of the
th century, Einstein's General Relativity (G.T.R.) employed the differential-geometric model of
-manifold equipped with a Lorentzian metric structure, the solution of the field equations which (the latter) correlate the Curvature of spacetime with the distribution of matter, the energy and the momentum ([5] , [7] , [12] , [14] ). That was the beginning of interconnections between geometry & physics.
The possibility that there may exist more than
space-time dimensions was taken into account not long after the final formulation of G.T.R.. Kaluza and Klein (K.-K.) unified
vacuum Relativity and classical electromagnetism ([15] ) on a
-manifold that satisfies the vacuum field equations (curved by the contribution of the photons). The extra dimension was considered topologically compact (homeomorphic to
), infinitesimal (thus invisible) and the
-spacetime was assumed not to depend on the 5th dimension. In fact, the Universe was considered as a hyper-cylinder, locally homeomorphic to
.
In a modern approach called Space-Time-Matter or Induced Matter Theory (S.T.M.) ([17] , [18] , [15] and references therein) these assumptions are removed and the result is the unification of G.T.R. & electromagnetism together with their sources (mass & charge ), expounded (the latter) as an artifact induced on the
-manifold, generated by the (non-linear) geometry of invisible extra spatial dimensions.
One of the most recent Cosmological scenarios concerning the geometric structure of the (classical) Universe introduced by L. Randall and R. Sundrum ([38] , [39] ) claims that the Universe of our perception is a (mem-)Brane of
dimensions (submanifold) embedded in a multi-dimensional (MD) Bulk of at least
dimensions.
The main ansatz for this (possibly moving in the Bulk) Brane is that matter is confined on the Brane and only gravity and electromagnetic fields can propagate on the bulk. Soon,
-Brane (& multi-Brane, colliding or not ) systems embedded Global Embedding of Analytic Branes in MD
Einstein Bulk into the same Bulk came into light, with possible MD singularities. Our visible Universe was thought of as
of those interacting Branes. Mathematically, these theories are modeled on a local embedding theorem of Riemannian Geometry, due to Campbell who was the first who stated it [2] , and Magaard ([8] , [31] ) who presented a strict proof (see [35] , [40] , [44] ): any analytic n-manifold can be locally and isometrically embedded into some other Ricci-flat of n+1 dimensions (
). In a sense, this is equivalent to the local embedding of Einstein 4D Relativity, into some 5D Relativity in the vacuum where no matter exists (”wood”, according to Einstein), but only geometrical properties (”marble”).
It becomes clear that in the light of these theories that are entirely based on differential-geometric (though local only) embeddings, new global results are needed, in order to provide a true supporting mathematical framework for Brane-Worlds, not depending on local coordinates. The necessity for embedding owes to the fact that the starting point of an MD gravitational-cosmological theory is the
-dimensional G.T.R. that has to be incorporated in the new MD context.
In recent work ([26] , [27] , [28] ) the author has proved that the Campbell-Magaard (C.-M.) Theorem (extended by Dahia & Romero in [17] on Einstein from Ricci-flat spaces ) holds true globally:
Any
-dimensional analytic semi-Riemannian manifold
has a global isometric analytic embedding into an Einstein manifold
of dimension
,
(
).
This
may admit (if desired) countable unsmoothable differential-topological singularities, which may be distinct points into spacetime or extended spatial anomalies ([27] ). These pathologies living into the complement
were expounded as wormholes connecting distant points of spacetime.
In addition, Any analytic semi-Riemannian manifolds
, ...,
have all a global isometric analytic embedding into an
-Einstein Bulk
as disjoint submanifolds, while both
&
split. The optimum dimensionality of
corresponds to embedding codimension
.
In this paper we combine certain ideas from the prequels, showing that the Einstein embedding manifold
of the Branes may admit
in codimension
& countable-many in
unsmoothable differential-topological singularities, Global Embedding of Analytic Branes in MD
Einstein Bulk which may be distinct points into spacetime or extended spatial anomalies. We also calculate the (reduced) Homology of the singular
we construct, which proves to obey a direct sum decomposition, independent of
, for all
's,
.
The process in the proofs is a slight modification of that presented in [26] & [27] .
We form a bulk that contains all the
's as disjoint submanifolds and using the known local embedding results and certain differential-geometric & topological arguments we obtain the requested global extension.
In Section 1 we state the results proved in the prequels. Section 2 contains the proof of the basic result stated above. In Section 3 we study the topology of such embedding Einstein spaces, giving a Homological description of the Einstein manifolds
we construct, illustrating the aforementioned splitting.
The analogous physical interpretation of the constructed pathological anomalies as wormholes connecting distant points of Bulk spacetime living in the extra dimensions holds in this case of multi-Brane systems too. We refer to [27] .
Notations: In the sequel, the terms Spacetime, Brane, Bulk will be used in the place of paracompact, Hausdorff, connected manifolds (finite dimensional), equipped with a semi-Riemannian metric structure and the corresponding Levi-Civita linear connection. Global Embedding of Analytic Branes in MD
Einstein Bulk
1. The Previous Results.
In [26] we proved that:
Theorem 1.1.
(Global Isometric Embedding into Einstein manifolds in codimension 1) Any
-dimensional real analytic semi-Riemannian manifold
has a global isometric embedding into an
-dimensional Einstein manifold
satisfying:
for any
.
It is worth noticing that the assumption of analyticity for the manifold is not restrictive, provided that any paracompact
-manifold,
, acquires a unique compatible not just smooth (
) but real analytic structure (there exists a
-diffeomorphism with an analytic manifold). See [45] , [24] , [10] .
Remark 1.2.
It is obvious that if a manifold can be embedded into an Einstein space as a hypersurface, repeated applications of Theorem 1.1 imply the weakercondition to be embedable in any codimension greater than
.
In [27] we extended further this result, so that to incorporate pathological singularities in the complement of the Bulk
that are non-removable:
Theorem 1.3.
(Embedding into Einstein manifold with unsmoothable differential-topological singularities of zero measure) Given a semi-Riemannian analytic manifold
, there exist:
(I) a topological space
(II) an analytic manifold
, with
,
(III) a countable set of points
, satisfying:
such that the following topological homeomorphism holds (under inclusion to a subspace)
and
is an Einstein space of global isometric analytic embedding for
.
In addition,
is not even a topological manifold and there does notexists any smoothing resolution of the singularities
.
denotes the (induced from the differential structure) topology of
.
The mathematical mechanism of topological identitification we used in the proof of 1.3 in [27] to produce the pathological singularities on the Bulk raised the idea that it is not really necessary these ”anomalies” to be points: there may exist extended problematic domains of the complement
. We simply identify distinct homeomorphic domains on the ”fibres”
.
This more realistic case may correspond to extended object in the Universe with positive (multi-dimensional) volume.
Theorem 1.4.
(Embedding into Einstein manifold with unsmoothable differential-topological singularities of positive
-measure) Given a semi-Riemannian analytic manifold
, there exist:
(I) a topological space
(II) an analytic manifold
, with
,
(III) countable many closed path connected & simply connected sets
, satisfying:
such that the following topological homeomorphism holds (under inclusion to a subspace) Global Embedding of Analytic Branes in MD
Einstein Bulk
and
is an Einstein space of global analytic isometric embedding for
.
In addition,
is not a topological manifold.
In [28] we showed that there exists a supporting embedding result for the multi-Brane models of Cosmology (see e.g. [42] ), due to the following result.
The method in the proof is a slight modification of the
-manifold embedding of [26] to produce an
admitting finite many submanifolds.
Theorem 1.5.
(Global Isometric Embedding of Branes into Einstein manifolds in codimension 1) Any
-dimensional analytic semi-Riemannian manifolds
,
(Branes) have all a global analytic isometric embedding into an
-dimensional Einstein manifold
satisfying:
as disjoint submanifolds for any
.
In this paper we continue with the reasonable extension of the last theorem concerning Brane embeddings incorporating singular spacetimes, in the sense in was done in [27] in the case of a single manifold embedding. Global Embedding of Analytic Branes in MD
Einstein Bulk
2. Embedding of Branes into
-Manifolds admitting Singularities.
The singularities we produce on
are by construction pathological and there does not exist any resolution of them: they are obtained by certain topological identitifications of distinct point and the obtain Bulk is not even a manifold, unless the singularities are extracted.
In other words, there exists an Einstein Bulk
imbedded (in the sense of analysis) into a topological space
, where the complement
has zero measure.
Theorem 2.1.
(Embedding into Einstein manifold with unsmoothable differential-topological singularities of zero measure) Given any analytic semi-Riemannian manifolds (Branes)
, . . .,
there exist:
(I) a topological space
(II) an analytic manifold
, with
,
(III) a countable set of points
, satisfying:
such that the following topological homeomorphism holds (under inclusion to a subspace)
and
is an Einstein space of global isometric analytic embedding for
,...,
.
In addition,
is not even a topological manifold and there does notexists any smoothing resolution of the singularities
.
-
Global Embedding of Analytic Branes in MD
Einstein Bulk
Proof.
Let
be the product of the given semi-Riemannian
's with an analytic manifold
,
satisfying the property:
”deleting any countable many points
from a
-dimensional and a single point
from an
-dimensional
, the respective complements
and
are connected.”
Its easy to see from the definition of
that we can rewrite it as the disjointunion of manifolds
For convenience, set
where
,
. Then,
,
.
Choose a countable set of points
of
(if
) or a single point
(if
). We will prove the general case for
reducing obviously to the trivial case when
.
The previous choice implies a choice of points for each
of
: Global Embedding of Analytic Branes in MD
Einstein Bulk
denoted as
Considering the (disjoint) union of all such points in
we may get a more subtle expression of them, as:
Define now a topological space
as the quotient space, produced identifying for each
in
and
, all the distinct points
as one
:
with the quotient topology, say
, induced by the topologies
and
. Global Embedding of Analytic Branes in MD
Einstein Bulk In the case of
-dimensional manifold
, this is exactly the wedge sum of the manifolds
with respect to (the
term sequence)
(each
is the chosen base point of
):
|
(2.1)
|
Back to the general case,
has a natural (product) analytic manifold structure. Deleting all the (countable many) distinct points
,
and
, we obtain an analytic connected manifold structure in the (open in the induced topology) complement:
If we set
then
with the obvious
-atlas
Global Embedding of Analytic Branes in MD
Einstein Bulk Deleting the sequence of (identified) points
of
, we obtain the differential-topological structure of an analytic manifold,
withoutany singularities, since:
that is
which proves the analytic structure on
. Applying now the embedding theorem 2.2 for this analytic manifold, we can make it an Einstein global isometric embedding manifold of
, . . .,
.
The remaining task is to show that
is not a manifold. To see this, suppose that taking the wedge sum of
distinct fibres
, there exists a homeomorphism of a domain
of
to
. If this holds, then there must exist a homeomorphism
choose an open ball
of maximum radius living into
and containing
. Then, the following homeomorphism
Global Embedding of Analytic Branes in MD
Einstein Bulk can nothold, since
has
connected component while
has
connected components.
The mathematical mechanism of topological identitification we used to produce the pathological singularities on the Bulk raises the idea that it is not really necessary these ”anomalies” to be points: there may exist extended problematic domains of the complement
. We simply identify distinct homeomorphic domains on the ”fibres”
.
This more realistic case may correspond to extended object in the Universe with positive (multi-dimensional) volume.
Theorem 2.2.
(Embedding into Einstein manifold with unsmoothable differential-topological singularities of positive
-measure) Given any finite-many analytic semi-Riemannian manifolds (Branes)
,. . .,
there exist:
(I) a topological space
(II) an analytic manifold
, with
,
(III) countable many closed path connected & simply connected sets
, satisfying:
such that the following topological homeomorphism holds (under inclusion to a subspace)
&
is an Einstein space of global isometric analytic embedding for
,...,
.
In addition,
is not a topological manifold.
-
Global Embedding of Analytic Branes in MD
Einstein Bulk
Proof.
The proof is a replica of the previous result. The only fact that needs to be noted is that extracting from a closed (abstract) curve a closed (image of ) an interval, (e.g. a closed arc from
) or a closed (image of a)
-ball from
(choosing e.g.
) for
), we obtain open submanifolds in the analytic subspace structure.
In addition, the unability of resolution of the singularities, owes to the fact that choosing from each of the
's a (diffeomorphic image of a) closed ball, the quotient space when they are all identified is not a manifold, by the same topological argument as in 2.1 , extracting a closed inversed image of ball instead of a point.
Countability of these ”extended anomalies” can be easily shown, since choosing for the (diffeomorphic images of ) balls,
, we can embed in
countable many balls, centered at the points of
. If
, it suffices to reduce embedding of balls to a
-dimensional linear subspace of
.
Global Embedding of Analytic Branes in MD
Einstein Bulk
3. Homology of the Branes' Global Embedding Singular Einstein Manifold
.
If we wish to give a topological description of the singular spacetime
as in Sec. 3 of [27] , we can use reduced Homology theory, since the axioms (e.g. [1] , [6] ) provide a direct sum splitting for the wedge topological sum of spaces.
The following gives a Homological description of the
with a single
-point singularity:
Proposition 3.1.
(Homology of Branes' Embedding Manifold
with
-point Singularity) The Einstein manifold
with
-point singularity, has the splitting (reduced) Homology
for any coefficient group
.
-
Proof.
The wedge sum relation 2.1 for
implies the following Homological splitting, due to the respective property of the singular theory:
and provided that the diffeomorphisms
,
imply the group isomorphisms
we obtain the direct sum splitting
as claimed.
Corollary 3.2.
Choosing in the case of
-codimensional Brane embedding the homotopy equivalence
, we obtain the following Einstein space Homology:
Acknowledgement. The Author is profoundly indebted to professor Lorenz Magaard at University of Honolulu, Hawaii for his interest in the present work, P. Krikelis & A. Kartsaklis at University of Athens for helpful comments & technical support and Ed. Anderson for discussions on the physical aspects of the embedding results.
References
-
Glen E. Bredon, Topology and Geometry, Springer, 1997
-
J. E. Campbell, A Course of Differential Geometry, Oxford, Clarendon Press, 1923
-
Do Carmo, M.P., Riemannian Geometry, Birkhaüser, 1992
-
L. Pf. Eisenhart, Riemannian Geometry, Princeton University Press, 1964
- Global Embedding of Analytic Branes in MD
Einstein Bulk
O. Gron and S. Hervik, Einstein's General Theory of Relativity (e-book), http://www.fys.uio.no/ sigbjorh/gravity.pdf, 2004
-
A. Hatcher, Algebraic Topology, http://www.math.cornell.edu/ hatcher, (e-book), 2000
-
S. W. Hawking & G. F. R. Ellis The Large scale structure of spacetime, Cambridge University Press, 1973
-
L. Magaard, Zur Einbettung Riemannscher Raume in Einstein Raume und Konfor Euclidische Raume, PhD thesis, (Kiel), 1963
-
J. R. Munkres, Topology, a first course, Prentice-Hall, Inc., Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey
-
R. Narasimhan, Analysis on Real and Complex Manifolds, Masson and Cie, Paris, North Holland, 1968
-
R. Penrose, Techniques of Differential Topology in Relativity, SIAM Publ. Philadelphia, 1972
-
R. K. Sachs and H. Wu, General Relativity for Mathematicians, Springer-Verlang, 1977
-
N. Steenrod, The topology of fibre Bundles, Princeton University Press, 1972
-
H. Stefani, General Relativity, 2nd Edition, Cambridge University Press, 1990
-
P. S. Wesson, Space-Time-Matter, Modern Kaluza-Klein Theory, World Scientific, 2000 (Articles)
-
E. Anderson, J. E. Lidsey, Embeddings in NonVacuum Spacetimes, Class.Quant.Grav. 18 (2001) 4831-4844, ArXiv: gr-qc/0106090
- Global Embedding of Analytic Branes in MD
Einstein Bulk
F. Dahia, C. Romero, The embedding of spacetime in
dimensions: An extension of Campbell-Magaard theorem, J.Math.Phys. 43 (2002) 5804-5814, ArXiv: gr-qc/0109076
-
F. Dahia, C. Romero, On the embedding of branes in five-dimensional spaces, Class.Quant.Grav. (2004) 21, No 4, 927-933, ArXiv: gr-qc/0308056
-
A. Davidson,
cosmology of a brane-like universe, Class. Quantum Grav. 16 (1999) 653 659
-
C. Deffayet, Cosmology of Brane-Induced Gravity Models, International Journal of Theoretical Physics, Vol. 41, No. 11, November 2002 http://www.kluweronline.com/article
-
M. Gogberashvili, Brane-Universe in Six Dimensions with Two Times, Phys.Lett. B484 (2000) 124-128, ArXiv: hep-ph/0001109
-
M. Gogberashvili, Embedding of the Brane into Six Dimensions, J.Math.Phys. 43 (2002) 4886 4888, ArXiv: gr-qc/0202061
-
M. Gogberashvili, Brane Gravity from Bulk Vector Field, Phys.Lett. B553 (2003) 284-288, ArXiv: hep-th/0203090
-
H. Grauert, On Levi's problem and the imbedding of real analytic manifolds, Annals of Mathematics, 68 (47-82)
-
E. Gravanis, S. Willison, Israel conditions for the Gauss-Bonnet theory and the Friedmann equation on the brane universe, ArXiv: hep-th/0209076
-
N. I. Katzourakis ”The Global Embedding Problem of SemiRiemannian into Einstein Manifolds”, ArXiv: math-ph/0407067
-
N. I. Katzourakis ”On the Global Embedding of Spacetime into Singular
Einstein Manifolds: Wormholes”, ArXiv: math.DG/0503129
-
N. I. Katzourakis ”Global Embedding of Analytic Branes into Einstein MD Bulk Cosmology”, ArXiv: math.DG/0411630
- Global Embedding of Analytic Branes in MD
Einstein Bulk
D. Langlois, Brane cosmology: an introduction, Prog.Theor.Phys.Suppl. 148 (2003) 181-212, ArXiv: hep-th/0209261
-
D. Langlois, Gravitation and Cosmology in Brane-Worlds, (Invited plenary talk at the GR17 conference, Dublin, Ireland, July 2004), ArXiv: gr-qc/0410129
-
J. E. Lidsey, C. Romero, R. Tavakol, S. Rippl, On Applications of Campbell's Embedding Theorem, Class.Quant.Grav. 14 (1997) 865-879, ArXiv: gr-qc/9907040
-
J. E. Lidsey, The Embedding of Superstring Backgrounds in Einstein Gravity, Phys.Lett. B417 (1998) 33, ArXiv: hep-th/9907095
-
R. Maartens, Geometry and Dynamics of the Brane-World, Reference Frames and Gravitomagnetism, ed. J Pascual-Sanchez et al. (World Sci., 2001), p. 93-119, ArXiv: gr-qc/0101059
-
R. Maartens, Brane-World Gravity, Living Rev. Relativity, 7, (2004), 7, http://www.livingreviews.org/lrr-2004-7
-
M. Pavisic, Resource Letter on Geometrical Results for Embeddings and Branes, arXiv: gr-qc/0010045
-
A. Perez-Lorenzana, An Introduction to the Brane World, ArXiv: hep-ph/0406279
-
F. Quevedo, Lectures on String/Brane Cosmology, arXiv: hep-th/0210292
-
L. Randall, R. Sundrum, A Large Mass Hierarchy from a Small Extra Dimension, Phys.Rev.Lett. 83 (1999) 3370-3373, ArXiv: hep-ph/9905221
-
L. Randall, R. Sundrum, An Alternative to Compactification, Phys.Rev.Lett. 83 (1999) 4690-4693, ArXiv: hep-th/9906064
-
S. S. Seahra, Physics in Higher-Dimensional Manifolds, http://etd.uwaterloo.ca/etd/ssseahra2003.pdf
- Global Embedding of Analytic Branes in MD
Einstein Bulk
S. S. Seahra, P. S. Wesson, Application of the CampbellMagaard theorem to higher-dimensional physics, Class.Quant.Grav. 20 (2003) 1321-1340, ArXiv: gr-qc/0302015
-
T. Shiromizu, K. Koyama, Low energy effective theory for two branes system Covariant curvature formulation, Phys.Rev. D67 (2003) 084022, ArXiv: hep-th/0210066
-
D. A. Steer, M. F. Parry, Brane Cosmology, Varying Speed of Light and Inflation in Models With One or More Extra Dimensions, Int.J.Th.Phys., Vol. 41, No. 11, Nov. 2002, http://www.kluweronline.com/article
-
D. Wands, Brane-world cosmology, http://www.tech.port.ac.uk/staffweb/wandsd/powerpoint/sussex.pdf
-
H. Whitney, Differentiable Manifolds, Annals of Mathematics, 37 (645-680), 1936