Pseudocyclic association schemes arising from the actions of
and
Henk D. L. Hollmann Philips Research Laboratories Prof. Holstlaan 4, 5656 AA Eindhoven The Netherlands email: henk.d.l.hollmann@philips.com Qing Xiang Department of Mathematical Sciences University of Delaware Newark, DE 19716, USA email: xiang@math.udel.edu
In Memory of Jack van Lint
Abstract
The action of
on the set of exterior lines to a nonsingular conic in
affords an association scheme, which was shown to be pseudocyclic in [
6]
. It was further conjectured in [
6]
that the orbital scheme of
on the set of exterior lines to a nonsingular conic in
is also pseudocyclic if
is an odd prime. We confirm this conjecture in this paper. As a by-product, we obtain a class of Latin square type strongly regular graphs on nonprime-power number of points.
1 Introduction
Let
be a finite set. A (symmetric) association scheme with
classes on
is a partition of
into sets
,
(called associate classes or relations) such that
-
1.
(the diagonal relation),
-
2.
is symmetric for
,
-
3.
for all
in
there is an integer
such that, for all
,
We denote such an association scheme by
. Elements
and
of
are called
-th associates if
. The numbers
,
, are called the intersection parameters of the scheme. That
exists means that there is a constant number of
-th associates of any element of
, which is usually denoted by
. The numbers
are called the valencies (or degrees) of the scheme. We have
-
1.
,
-
2.
(Kronecker delta),
,
-
3.
,
.
For
, let
be the adjacency matrix of the relation
, that is, the rows and columns of
are both indexed by
and
The matrices
are symmetric
-matrices and
where
is the all one matrix of size
by
. By the definition of an association scheme, we have
for any
. So
form a basis of the commutative algebra generated by
over the reals (which is called the Bose-Mesner algebra of the association scheme). Moreover this algebra has a unique basis
of primitive idempotents; one of the primitive idempotents is
. So we may assume that
.
Let
. Then
The numbers
are called the multiplicities of the scheme. Since we have two bases of the Bose-Mesner algebra, we may consider the transition matrices between them. Define
(the first eigenmatrix) and
(the second eigenmatrix) as the
matrices with rows and columns indexed by
such that
and
Of course, we have
Note that
is the set of eigenvalues of
and the zeroth row and column of
and
are as indicated below.
Before we proceed further, we give some examples of association schemes.
Example 1.1
Let
be a finite set and let
be a group acting transitively on
. We say that
acts generously transitively on
if the orbits of the induced action of
on
are all symmetric. (The orbits of
on
are usually called the orbitals of the action of
on
.) It is clear that if
acts generously transitively on
, then the orbitals of
on
can be taken as the relations of an association scheme, which will be called the orbital scheme of
on
. The next example arises in this way.
Example 1.2
We consider cyclotomic schemes defined as follows. Let
be a prime power and let
with
. Let
be the subgroup of the multiplicative group of
of index
, and let
be the cosets of
. We require
. Define
, and for
, define
. Then
is an
-class symmetric association scheme (the
are the orbitals of the action of
on
, where
). The intersection parameters of the cyclotomic scheme are related to the cyclotomic numbers ([
12,p. 25]
).
Namely, for
, given
,
|
(1)
|
The first eigenmatrix
of this scheme is the following
by
matrix (with the rows of
arranged in a certain way)
with
, where
is the
by
matrix:
and
,
, for a fixed nontrivial additive character
of
. See [
1]
for more details.
Next we introduce the notion of a pseudocyclic association scheme.
Definition 1.3
Let
be an association scheme. We say that
is pseudocyclic if there exists an integer
such that
for all
.
The following theorem gives combinatorial characterizations for an association scheme to be pseudocyclic.
Theorem 1.4
Let
be an association scheme, and for
and
, let
. Then the following are equivalent.
(1).
is pseudocyclic.
(2). For some constant
, we have
and
, for
.
(3).
is a
design, where
.
For a proof of this theorem, we refer the reader to [2,p. 48] and [6,p. 84] . Part (2) in the above theorem is very useful. For example, we may use it to prove that the cyclotomic scheme in Example 1.2 is pseudocyclic. The proof goes as follows. First, the nontrivial valencies of the cyclotomic scheme in Example 1.2 are all equal to
. Second, by ( 1 ) and noting that
, we have
| |
Pseudocyclic schemes can be used to construct strongly regular graphs and distance regular graphs of diameter 3 ([3] , [2,p. 388] ). In view of this, it is of interest to construct pseudocyclic association schemes, as remarked by the authors of [2] (see [2,p. 389] ). The cyclotomic schemes are examples of pseudocyclic association schemes on prime-power number of points. Very few examples of pseudocyclic association schemes on nonprime-power number of points are currently known (see [11] , [2,p. 390] and [6] ). One class of such examples comes from the action of
on the set of exterior lines to a nonsingular conic in
. We will give a quick review of this class of association schemes in Section 2, and also include a proof of the pseudocyclicity of these association schemes. In [6] , it was further conjectured that the orbital scheme of
on the set of exterior lines to a nonsingular conic in
is also pseudocyclic if
is an odd prime. We will confirm this conjecture in Section 3. As a by-product, we obtain a class of Latin square type strong regular graphs on nonprime-power number of points.
2 The Elliptic Schemes
In the rest of this paper, we always assume that
, where
is a positive integer.
Let
Then
is a nonsingular conic in
. A line of
is called exterior (resp.
secant) if it meets
in 0 (resp. 2) points. Let
(resp.
) be the set of exterior (resp.
secant) lines to
. Then
The subgroup of
fixing
setwise is isomorphic to
(cf. [5,p. 158] ).
Hence
acts on
and
, respectively. Moreover, it is shown in [8] that
acts generously transitively on both
and
. Therefore we obtain two association schemes, one on
and the other on
. The association scheme on
will be called the elliptic scheme, and the association scheme on
is called the hyperbolic scheme.
Since the point
is the nucleus of
(i.e., the point at which all tangent lines to
meet), we see that each line in
can be written as
for some
. Let
be the trace map. Also for
we define
and
. Then
is in
(resp.
) if and only if
(resp.
). Given two lines
and
, we define
We remark that the function
comes from the cross-ratio of four points on a projective line (see [8] for details). The following theorem in [8] gives a simple description of the orbitals of the action of
on
by using the function
.
Theorem 2.1
The orbitals of the action of
on
are
(the diagonal class), and
for all
.
There is a similar description of the orbitals of
on
in [8] . Since we are only concerned with the elliptic scheme in this paper, we omit that description. The pair
is an association scheme on
with
classes. The intersection parameters of this scheme are computed in [8] . For
, given
, we use
to denote
. We have:
Theorem 2.2
Let
. Then for any
,
|
(2)
|
where the last sum is over the two elements
satisfying
. Also for all
, the valency
.
The association scheme
is pseudocyclic. This is already known in [6] . For convenience of the reader, we include a proof here.
Theorem 2.3
The association scheme
is pseudocyclic.
Proof: By Theorem 2.2 , the nontrivial valencies of the association scheme
are all equal to
. By Part (2) of Theorem 1.4 , it suffices to prove that
for all
.
By Theorem 2.2 , for
, we have
Fixing
with
, we have
| |
| |
| |
This completes the proof.
3 Pseudocyclic fusion schemes of the elliptic schemes
As we have seen in the last section, the elliptic scheme
is pseudocyclic. In this section, we will consider the fusion scheme of
obtained by merging the classes
via the Frobenius automorphism
of
. Specifically, for
, define
where
. Let
be a set of orbit representatives of
under the action of the Frobenius automorphism. Then
, and
,
are the orbitals of
on
. Therefore
is also an association scheme. The (nontrivial) intersection parameters of this fusion scheme will be denoted by
, where
.
We have for
,
where
. (This is independent of the choice of
.) Now, if
is prime, then each
,
, has size
, so the nontrivial valencies of the fusion scheme
are all equal to
. Hollmann [6,p. 133] made the following conjecture.
Conjecture 3.1
If
is an odd prime, then
is pseudocyclic.
As far as we know, there is no published proof of this conjecture. There is one sentence on Page 390 of [2] stating the above conjecture as a fact. But this was not backed up by a proof.
Note that the nontrivial valencies of
are all equal to
when
is prime. So in order to prove Conjecture 3.1 , by Part (2) of Theorem 1.4 , we need to show that
|
(3)
|
for all
. (Here we implicitly used the fact that
since all nontrivial valencies are all equal when
is prime.) Simplifying the left hand side of ( 3 ), we see that ( 3 ) is equivalent to
|
(4)
|
Now, the
term of the left hand side of ( 4 ) is equal to
as seen in the proof of Theorem 2.3 . So in order to prove ( 4 ), we have to show that
|
(5)
|
for all
.
We will prove a stronger result:
Theorem 3.2
Let
be an odd integer, and let
be any integer in
satisfying
. Write
. Then
|
(6)
|
for all
.
The most important ingredient in our proof of Theorem 3.2 is a family of polynomials
introduced in [7] . In fact we discovered these polynomials while working on a proof of Theorem 3.2 . We now define the polynomials
and quote the main theorem from [7] .
Let
be an integer, let
be any integer in
with
, and let
be such that
(mod
). Write
and use
to denote the following polynomial in
.
For
in
, we define the polynomial
(Note that
is indeed a polynomial in
with coefficients in
and
.
Also see [7] for connections between
and the Dickson polynomials.) The following is the main theorem from [7] .
Theorem 3.3
Let
be positive integers with
, let
be such that
, and let
. Then the mapping
,
, maps
bijectively to
, and maps
bijectively to
. In particular, the polynomial
is a permutation polynomial of
if and only if
(mod 2).
We are now ready to give the proof of Theorem 3.2 .
Proof of Theorem 3.2 : Recall that from Theorem 2.2 , for
,
| |
where
is any element with
. Since
and
is odd, we can find a unique
such that
. So
| |
| |
For convenience, we define
Our goal is to prove that
for all
.
For later use, we define the polynomial
where
is an integer satisfying
(mod
).
Since
and
is odd, we can write
with
. Then the equation
involved in the definition of
becomes
|
(7)
|
Noting that
is odd, we see that for any
, there is a unique solution
of ( 7 ), namely
where in the last equality we used the fact that
. Therefore we have
| |
We will consider the
odd case and the
even case separately.
Case 1.
is odd. Let
, where
and
. Then
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
where in the last step, we used
. Now noting that for
,
(One can prove this directly, or see Lemma 3.1 in [7] .) Therefore, in this case, we have
|
(8)
|
For the first summand in ( 8 ), noting that
and
maps
to
bijectively (Theorem 3.3 ), we have
| |
| |
Since
is a
(Singer) difference set in the cyclic group
, and
, we see that
. Hence
For the second summand in ( 8 ), using
, we see that
For any
, we have
| |
| |
| |
Also by Theorem 3.3 ,
maps
bijectively to
. Hence
| |
Therefore we have
Case 2.
is even. This case is similar to Case 1 and actually easier. Let
. By the same computations as those in the
odd case, we find that
By Theorem 3.3 ,
maps
bijectively to
, and maps
bijectively to
.
Therefore,
| |
| |
| |
In summary, in both cases, we have shown that
for all
. The proof is complete.
Remark 3.4
More general results can be proved in the same fashion as above. Let
. Define
Then using the same arguments as those in the proof of Theorem 3.2 , we find that
,
, and
, for all
.
Now we can finish the proof of Conjecture 3.1 .
Theorem 3.5
If
is an odd prime, then
is pseudocyclic.
Proof: Since
is prime, the nontrivial valencies of the scheme are all equal to
.
To finish the proof, we need to prove ( 3 ) for all
. As we have seen in the analysis before the statement of Theorem 3.2 , ( 3 ) is equivalent to ( 5 ). Since
is an odd prime, any integer
is relatively prime to
. So we can apply Theorem 3.2 to obtain
for all
. Now ( 5 ) follows. This completes the proof.
4 Latin square type strongly regular graphs
A strongly regular graph srg
is a graph with
vertices that is regular of valency
and that has the following properties:
-
1.
For any two adjacent vertices
, there are exactly
vertices adjacent to both
and
.
-
2.
For any two nonadjacent vertices
, there are exactly
vertices adjacent to both
and
.
It is well known [9,p. 407] that strongly regular graphs are equivalent to two-class association schemes. An srg
is said to be of Latin square type if
where
. Any Latin square of order
gives rise to a Latin square type srg (actually called Latin square graph in this case) with parameters
(see [9,p. 273] ). Many examples of Latin square type srg on prime-power number of points are known [10] . In contrast, not too many examples of Latin square type srg on nonprime-power number of points are known.
In [3] , it was shown that pseudocyclic association schemes can give rise to Latin square type srg. We quote the following theorem from [3] . A proof can be found in [4] .
Theorem 4.1
Let
be a pseudocyclic association scheme on
points.
Then the graph
whose vertex set is
, and where two distinct vertices
and
are adjacent if and only if
and
for some
, is a Latin square type srg with parameters
Using Theorem 4.1 , one can obtain Latin square type srg from the pseudocyclic association scheme
(the elliptic scheme). These srg have parameters
We note that the Latin square type srg arising from
were mentioned in [4] , in which another construction of these srg was given. Now since we have shown that the fusion scheme
of the elliptic scheme
is also pseudocyclic when
is an odd prime. We obtain more Latin square type srg via Theorem 4.1 .
Theorem 4.2
Let
, where
is an odd prime. Then there exists a Latin square type srg with parameters
where
and
.
Proof: Straightforward.
Acknowledgements: The second author thanks Philips Research Eindhoven, the Netherlands, where part of this work was carried out. The research of the second author is supported in part by NSF grant DMS 0400411.
References
-
E. Bannai and A. Munemasa, Davenport-Hasse theorem and cyclotomic schemes, unpublished notes.
-
A. E. Brouwer, A. M. Cohen, and A. Neumaier, Distance Regular Graphs, Ergebnisse der Mathematik und ihrer Grenzgebiete (3) [Results in Mathematics and Related Areas (3)], 18. Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1989.
-
A. E. Brouwer and R. Mathon, unpublised notes.
-
T. Fujisaki, A four-class association scheme derived from a hyperbolic quadric in
, Adv. Geom. 4 (2004), 105–117.
-
J. W. P. Hirschfeld, Projective Geometries over Finite Fields, Second edition. Oxford Mathematical Monographs. The Clarendon Press, Oxford University Press, New York, 1998.
-
Henk D. L. Hollmann, Association schemes, Master Thesis, Eindhoven University of Technology, 1982.
-
Henk D. L. Hollmann and Qing Xiang, A class of permutation polynomials of
related to Dickson polynomials, Finite Fields Appl. 11 (2005), 111–122.
-
Henk D. L. Hollmann and Qing Xiang, Association schemes arising from the action of
fixing a nonsingular conic in
, submitted. Preprint available at http://www.math.udel.edu/
xiang/paper.html
-
J. van Lint and R. M. Wilson, A Course in Combinatorics, Second edition, Cambridge University Press, 2001.
-
S. L. Ma, A survey of partial difference sets, Des. Codes Cryptogr. 4 (1994), 221–261.
-
R. Mathon,
-class association schemes, Proceedings of the Conference on Algebraic Aspects of Combinatorics (Univ. Toronto, Toronto, Ont., 1975), 123–155. Congressus Numerantium, No. XIII, Utilitas Math., Winnipeg, Man., 1975.
-
T. Storer, Cyclotomy and Difference Sets, Lectures in Advanced Mathematics, No. 2 Markham Publishing Co., Chicago, Ill. 1967