1991 Mathematics Subject Classification. Primary 47B36, 39A70; Secondary 34L25. The work was partially supported by INTAS grant no. 03-51-6637.
The discrete spectrum for complex perturbations of periodic Jacobi matrices
Iryna Egorova
Leonid Golinskii
Institute for Low Temperature Physics and Engineering, 47, Lenin Ave, Kharkiv, Ukraine E-mail address : egorova@ilt.kharkov.ua Institute for Low Temperature Physics and Engineering, 47, Lenin Ave, Kharkiv, Ukraine E-mail address : golinskii@ilt.kharkov.ua
-
Abstract.
We study spectrum inclusion regions for complex Jacobi matrices which are compact perturbations of real periodic Jacobi matrix. The condition sufficient for the lack of discrete spectrum for such matrices is given.
1 Introduction
The main object under investigation is an infinite complex Jacobi matrix
, which is a compact perturbation of a real symmetric periodic matrix
of period
(background). The spectrum of the background as an operator in
is known to be a union of at most
bands divided by gaps, each of which may carry at most one eigenvalue. Since compact perturbations preserve the continuous spectrum we are primarily interested in the location of the discrete spectrum of
. According to the general results of operator theory for small in norm perturbations the spectrum of perturbed operator is settled in a small vicinity of the spectrum of the background.
A specific feature of the given situation is that the spectrum is accumulated near the edges of bands and near the discrete spectrum of the background. Whereas a qualitative picture holds for any value of
, we find certain quantitative bounds for the size of domain where the discrete spectrum lives only for
. In this case we also show that the discrete spectrum of
is empty provided the spectrum of the background is pure continuous and the first moment of perturbation is small enough.
We proceed as follows. In Section 2 we present some basic facts from the spectral theory of periodic Jacobi matrices. The key tool of our investigation the discrete integral equation for the Jost solution of the Jacobi difference equation (three term recurrence relation) for the perturbed matrix
is introduced in Section 3. In Section 4 we describe the algorithm of reconstruction of a 2-periodic matrix from its Borg sequence (lemma 4.1 ) and obtain a new representation for the Floquet solution (lemma 4.3 ). Finally, in the last Section 5 we prove the main results of the paper.
Let
be Jacobi matrices with the entries
and
| |
| |
be the Jacobi difference equations, which correspond to the matrices
and
, respectively. We assume that either the zero moment
or the first moment
of the perturbation is finite, where
|
(1.1)
|
With no loss of generality we may suppose that the continuous spectrum of the background
is a set of the form
Put
when
has an eigenvalue
,
, and
otherwise (this is actually the case when
is an eigenvalue of the Jacobi matrix with shifted entries
,
or
)1
. Let
,
, be the Floquet multiplier (see (2.9 )) of
. The following result holds.
Theorem 1.1.
Let
, where the value
is given in
.
Then in the domain of variable
, defined by the relation
|
(1.2)
|
with
being a unique positive root of the equation
and
the operator
has no discrete spectrum at all.
It can be seen from (1.2 ), that if perturbation
is small enough, the discrete spectrum of
is concentrated near the edges of bands (which are exactly the points satisfying equation
) and in a vicinity of the point
, as long as it is an eigenvalue of
(i.e.,
), or
. We can also observe that even if
is not an eigenvalue of
, its position relative to the edge of the gap exerts certain influence on the size of the domain where the discrete spectrum of
is contained.
In the case when the first moment is small enough we have
Theorem 1.2.
Let the background
has pure continuous spectrum and
. Let
and
be taken from theorem 1.1. Then under assumption
the complex Jacobi matrix
has no discrete spectrum.
Our work was obviously very strongly influenced by Geronimo and Van Assche [7] , wherein the behavior of the Jost solutions for real perturbations of a periodic Jacobi matrix was investigated (see also [1,Section7] ). More detailed analysis of such solutions in the case
is based upon the reconstruction algorithm for a periodic Jacobi matrix from its Borg sequence, suggested in [5] .
In conclusion let us point out that the similar problems for the case of constant background (
,
) are discussed in [4] (see also [6] ).
2 Preliminaries on periodic spectral problem
Let
be an infinite Jacobi matrix with
periodic entries,
,
Put
and consider the three term equation
|
(2.1)
|
The solutions
and
of `
' and `
' type, defined by the initial data
,
, are polynomials with real coefficients of degree
and
respectively, and also
The Wronskian
of these two solutions does not depend on
and by periodicity of
or
|
(2.2)
|
The following two polynomials with real coefficients
|
(2.3)
|
|
(2.4)
|
are of particular interest. The first one,
, known as the Hill discriminant, characterizes the continuous spectrum of the operator
in the space
. Indeed, as is known by [2,Chapter4] , the spectrum
is a union of at most
disjoint closed intervals (bands) which constitute the continuous spectrum
with at most one eigenvalue inside each gap
(they form the discrete spectrum
). The continuous spectrum is related to the Hill discriminant by
(see [2,Section7.1] ). Throughout the paper we assume that
, i.e., an equation
has no multiple zeros. Hence
and
By (2.3 )
and
as
. The behavior of
for
is determined by the parity of
.
Consider the function
where the branch of the square root is taken positive for
. This function is real-valued inside the gaps
in such a way that
. On the set
it takes pure imaginary values.
The Weyl function
for periodic Jacobi matrices
is known to be of the form (see [3,formula(21.3.20)] )
Denote by
the set of all poles of
, which is clearly a subset of the set
of all roots of the polynomials
(they all are real and simple and
We assume that all
stay strictly inside the gaps, that is
|
(2.5)
|
The Weyl solution
of (2.1 ) is defined in a standard way
for
Along with the function
consider the function 2
It is easy to see from (2.2 )-(2.4 ) that
|
(2.6)
|
and so one of the functions
has a pole at each point
and the other a removable singularity .
Let us introduce the second solution of (2.1 )
As the Wronskian
the solutions
and
are linearly independent off the endpoints of
. Note also that
for
, and both solutions take real values for
. It follows from the properties of the Weyl functions
that for
the only one of
may have a pole at
. For
they both are continuous at
.
The typical feature of the periodic Jacobi difference equation is the existence of a special solution of (2.1 ) known as the Floquet solution
, which satisfies
|
(2.7)
|
Here
is the Floquet multiplier (see [1] ), with
for
and
for
. It is clear that
for
, and so it agrees up to a constant multiplier with the Weyl solution. We can put
. In addition by ([1,formula(7.19)] ) for the second solution
|
(2.8)
|
holds. Following [7] we introduce the function
:
|
(2.9)
|
It defines a conformal mapping of the upper
and lower
half-planes onto the lower
and upper
half-disks with cuts
|
(2.10)
|
where
and
are the points of local extremum of the Hill discriminant
,
(see [5,p.110] ). Moreover, the upper side of the interval
goes to the circular arc with endpoints
and
the lower side goes to the symmetric arc on the upper semicircle. The gap
viewed as a part of the boundary of
is mapped on both sides of the cut
, in such a way that
corresponds to the vertex of the cut and
,
to
, respectively. As a part of the boundary of
the gap
goes to the symmetric cut
. The infinite gaps
and
are mapped onto
and
, respectively;
for
. Hence the points
correspond to
and each point from
has two symmetric images on symmetric sides of the cuts.
Consider the functions
and
as functions of variable
for
. Then they have continuous boundary values with
|
(2.11)
|
Note that by (2.7 ),(2.8 ) and (2.9 ) the equalities
|
(2.12)
|
hold, where
,
are
periodic functions.
3 Integral equation
Take an infinite Jacobi matrix
and the related three term recurrence relation
|
(3.1)
|
We assume that the matrix entries
,
and
are close to
periodic sequences
in the following sense
|
(3.2)
|
It is convenient to modify (3.1 ) by changing the variables
(the infinite product converges due to (3.2 )). For
we have
|
(3.3)
|
Under the Green function (for the unperturbed problem) we mean
|
(3.4)
|
where the Weyl solutions
,
are defined in Section 2. It is easy to check that
where
is the Kronecker symbol.
The key role throughout the rest of the paper is played by the discrete integral equation (cf. [1,formulae(7.87)-(7.88)]
|
(3.5)
|
with the kernel
|
(3.6)
|
Let us show that each solution of (3.5 ) satisfies (3.3 ) and has the following asymptotic behavior for
:
Indeed, by the definition
| |
| |
We apply the `unperturbed' operator to both parts of (3.5 )
| |
| |
| |
or
which gives exactly (3.3 ).
Multiply (3.5 ) through by
, where
is defined in (2.9 ):
|
(3.7)
|
or
|
(3.8)
|
with
Equation (3.8 ) is analyzed thoroughly in [7,Theorem3] , for real symmetric Jacobi matrices
. The existence of the solution
such that
uniformly on compact subsets of the domain
has been established (the reason for the factor
to enter the asymptotic relation is to `suppress' poles of
).
We will be interested in the bounds of the form
wherein a positive function
is given explicitly in terms of the spectral data of the background and uniformly bounded off certain small neighborhoods of the set
,
|
(3.9)
|
We solve this problem completely for the case
, that is performed later on.
In the rest of this section we show how the method of successive approximations works in connection with equation (3.8 ). Appropriate bounds (see lemma 5.2 ) for the kernel
lead to the uniform convergence of the series
|
(3.10)
|
on compact subsets of the domain
, and moreover
Put
and prove by induction that
Then the required solution of (3.8 ) is given by
|
(3.11)
|
In particular for
thanks to
we have
which makes it possible to describe the region of the variable
wherein
.
The similar argument (with slightly different bounds) holds under the assumption
|
(3.12)
|
It remains only to point out that the set of zeros of the function
agrees with the set of eigenvalues (discrete spectrum) of the operator
off
.
4 Reconstruction of matrix of period 2 from spectral data
Let
be a real symmetric Jacobi matrix of period 2 with the matrix entries
,
. The first few polynomials
,
can be easily computed from recurrence relation (2.1 ):
|
(4.1)
|
The Hill discriminant
|
(4.2)
|
is a quadratic parabola with the positive leading coefficient. Hence the bands of continuous spectrum
are symmetric with respect to the vertex of this parabola and have the same length. By shifting the spectral parameter we can put the vertex to the origin. Denote the endpoints of the spectrum by
. Then
|
(4.3)
|
whence it follows that
and
|
(4.4)
|
Let
be a root of the polynomial
. By the assumption (2.5 ) we have
. Put
in the case when the Weyl function
has a pole at
and
otherwise. Our goal here is to restore the matrix
from its Borg sequence
and to derive a formula for the Weyl function as a function of variable
(2.9 ), which is related to
by the equality
|
(4.5)
|
By comparing (4.2 ) and (4.4 ) we come to the relations for the matrix entries:
|
(4.6)
|
and
|
(4.7)
|
so that
,
are roots of the quadratic equation
Hence
| |
|
(4.8)
|
where
,
and
designates the arithmetic value of the square root.
Let us show that
is equivalent to
. To this end write
| |
| |
and so
|
(4.9)
|
With regard to (4.8 ) and (4.3 ) (see also (2.6 )) the latter gives
and therefore
. In two-band case the Weyl function admits representation
and has a pole if and only if
, that is equivalent to
by (4.9 ).
Thus we come to the following
Lemma 4.1.
The entries of a two-periodic Jacobi matrix can be restored from the Borg sequence
by the formulae:
Corollary 4.2.
The following inequalities hold
|
(4.10)
|
Our next problem is to find effective bounds for the Weyl solution, more precisely, for the function
in terms of the variable
. As
,
, we only need estimate the function
. By the definition of
and in view of (4.5 ) we have
|
(4.11)
|
Remind that in the two-band case
.
Lemma 4.3.
The following representation holds
|
(4.12)
|
-
Proof.
The wronskian of two solutions
and
does not depend on
so
that is
|
(4.13)
|
Since (see Section 1)
,
, it follows from (4.13 ), (2.1 ), (4.1 ) and theorem 4.1 that
| |
| |
| |
i.e.,
and hence
|
(4.14)
|
But by (4.3 ), (4.4 ), (4.7 ) and theorem 4.1
that is
Relations (4.11 ), (4.5 ) imply
|
(4.15)
|
Next we plague (4.15 ) into (4.14 ) and take into account (4.7 ):
|
(4.16)
|
which proves (4.12 ) since
. □
5 Bounds for solutions of integral equation
The bounds in the method of successive approximations displayed in Section 3 for the case
is based upon explicit expressions for
and the Weyl functions
. We begin with the following simple result.
Lemma 5.1.
Let
and
. Put
|
(5.1)
|
For
consider the functions
where the branch of the square root is taken positive for
.
Then
|
(5.2)
|
|
(5.3)
|
-
Proof.
We have
, where
and so
The function
is analytic in
,
and
An elementary analysis of the function
shows that
|
(5.4)
|
i.e.,
. By Schwarz's Lemma
for
and hence the second inequality in (5.2 ) follows from (5.4 ).
The below bound for the function
comes out in a similar manner:
by Schwarz's Lemma
, which leads to (5.3 ). □
Let us next turn to the kernel
(3.6 ), (3.7 ).
Lemma 5.2.
The following inequalities take place
|
(5.5)
|
where
|
(5.6)
|
-
Proof.
Consider the expression
|
(5.7)
|
For the denominator in (5.7 ) we have
| |
| |
The functions
in the numerator are 2-periodic, and also
Thereby we have 4 different expressions for the right hand side (5.7 ):
|
(5.8)
|
|
(5.9)
|
|
(5.10)
|
|
(5.11)
|
with
We can estimate right hand sides in (5.8 ) -(5.11 ) by using the explicit formulae for
,
,
. Assume first that
. Then
| |
| |
so that
By lemma 5.1
|
(5.12)
|
The Weyl function is easily seen to satisfy as
| |
| |
By the definition of
(5.1 ) and the property (5.4 ) it is not hard to derive
and so the application of lemma 5.1 gives
|
(5.13)
|
(in the later inequality we use
(see (4.10 )). In the same way
| |
| |
and by lemma 5.1
|
(5.14)
|
Finally
and as above in (5.12 )
|
(5.15)
|
For
the argument is much more elementary and is based on
:
|
(5.16)
|
|
(5.17)
|
and the same estimate holds for
.
It is clear that the worst bound comes in (5.13 ) and thus we arrive at the following inequalities
|
(5.18)
|
The desired result now stems from (5.18 ) and the definition of the kernel
. □
An application of (5.12 ) and (4.10 ) to (4.12 ) gives
| |
|
(5.19)
|
and in fact this bound is true for all
.
We are now in a position to estimate the solution of equation (3.8 )
|
(5.20)
|
with constants expressed explicitly in terms of the spectral data for the 2-periodic background. Assume first that
|
(5.21)
|
By (5.19 ) and lemma 5.2 the first series in (5.20 ) converges uniformly on compact subsets of the domain
|
(5.22)
|
and its sum is subject to
|
(5.23)
|
is defined in (3.9 ),
as
. Hence for
we have (cf.(3.11 ))
|
(5.24)
|
which leads to the following result.
Theorem 5.3.
In assumption
there exists a solution
of equation
which satisfies
|
(5.25)
|
where
is given in
,
and
,
is defined in
.
Inequality (5.25 ) with
implies
Taking into account the spectral interpretation of zeros of the Jost function
we can draw the following conclusion.
Corollary 5.4.
Define the domain
in
-plain by inequality
|
(5.26)
|
where
is a unique positive root of the equation
.
Then
is free from the discrete spectrum of
.
In the case when the first moment of the perturbation is finite
|
(5.27)
|
the bounds for the Green kernel are performed in a slightly different way by using a simple inequality
For the right hand sides in (5.8 ) and (5.11 ) we see that
| |
| |
Next, for (5.9 )
where
| |
| |
and so
and
Hence
The similar inequality holds for
. Finally,
The method of successive approximations of Section 3 is applicable and provides the bound for the solution of the basic integral equation in assumption (5.27 ):
where
is defined in (5.24 ),
We are aimed here at the condition which guarantees the lack of discrete spectrum for the operator
. That is why it seems reasonable to suppose that the background operator
has pure continuous spectrum, i.e., in our notation
. Then
and hence
that gives the following result.
Theorem 5.5.
The operator
has no discrete spectrum as long as
References
-
G. Teschl, Jacobi Operators and Completely Integrable Nonlinear Lattices Math. Surv. and Mon.,Vol. 72, AMS, Rhode Island, 2000.
-
M. Toda, Theory of Nonlinear Lattices, Springer, Berlin, 1981.
-
E. Titchmarsh, Eigenfunction Expansions Associated with Second-Order Differential Equations, Part II, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1958.
-
I. Egorova, L. Golinskii, On location of discrete spectrum for complex Jacobi matrices, to appear in Proc. AMS
-
L. Percolab, Inverse problem for periodic Jacobi matrix,Teor. funk., funk. anal., pril., 42 (1984), 107-121.
-
V. Lyantse, Spectrum and resolvent of a non-selfconjugate difference operator,Ukr. Math. J., 20, no.4 (1968), 489-503.
-
J. Geronimo, W. Van Assche, Orthogonal polynomials with asymptotically periodic recurrence coefficients, J.of Approx. Theory , 46 (1986), 251-283.
Institute for Low Temperature Physics and Engineering, 47, Lenin Ave, Kharkiv, Ukraine E-mail address : egorova@ilt.kharkov.ua Institute for Low Temperature Physics and Engineering, 47, Lenin Ave, Kharkiv, Ukraine E-mail address : golinskii@ilt.kharkov.ua