A note on Veronese varieties
Margherita Barile
†
†
Partially supported by PRIN Algebra Commutativa e Computazionale, Italian Ministry of Education,University and Research. Dipartimento di Matematica, Università di Bari, Via E. Orabona 4, 70125 Bari, Italy e-mail:barile@dm.uniba.it
November 27, 2006
Abstract
We show that for every prime
, there is a class of Veronese varieties which are set-theoretic complete intersections if and only if the ground field has characteristic
.
Introduction An affine or projective variety
is called a set-theoretic complete intersection if it can be defined by the least possible number of equations, i.e., by codim
equations. This property can depend upon the characteristic of the ground field, but not many examples of this kind have been discovered so far. In [2] the authors describe a class of codimension 2 toric varieties which are set-theoretic complete intersections only in one positive characteristic. In this paper we show that there is a class of Veronese varieties, of arbitrarily high codimension, having the same property. We shall present them by means of their parametrizations as toric varieties, which will enable us to apply the criteria on the associated semigroup developed in [3] . We shall also use cohomological methods to provide lower bounds for the minimum number of defining equations.
1 Preliminary results
Let
be an algebraically closed field. Let
be a prime number,
a positive integer and
an integer. Consider the following subset of
:
where
is the standard basis of
. With every
we can associate the
-uple
and this defines a bijection between
and the set
|
(1)
|
We know that
. In the affine space
we fix the coordinates
,
. With
we can associate the simplicial affine toric variety
, defined by the following parametrization:
It has codimension
. In the sequel, for the sake of simplicity, we shall set
. Note that
is the affine cone over the projective toric variety of
having the same parametrization; the latter is called Veronese variety, and was extensively studied by Gröbner [6] .
We consider the polynomial ring
, and, in view of ( 1 ), we define the content of the indeterminate
as the set (with repeated elements):
More generally, the content of a product of indeterminates will be the (disjoint) union of the contents of its factors. Let
be the defining ideal of
in
. Then
is generated by binomials. Clearly, given two monomials
, we have that
if and only if
and
have the same content. We have just established the following
Proposition 1
The binomials in
are the (non zero) differences (*)
, where
is a positive integer, and
any element of the symmetric group
.
Remark 1
We have that
if and only if
for some
. This occurs if and only if
has a monomial factor.
Example 1
For
,
, and
the variety
admits the following parametrization
The ideal
is minimally generated by the following six quadratic binomials:
In general we have
Theorem 1
is generated by its binomials of degree 2.
Proof .-Let
the set of binomials of type (*) having degree 2. Let
be any non zero binomial of type (*), and suppose that
, where, for all
,
is a 2-cycle. In view of Remark 1, we can skip all
which involve two indices belonging to the same indeterminate. Up to a change of indices we may thus assume that
. We prove that
by induction on
. First suppose that
. Then
, so that
| |
| |
| |
where the term in brackets belongs to
. Hence
. Now assume that
and suppose the claim true for
. We have:
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
Induction applies to
, so that
in this case, too.
This completes the proof.
The previous lemma was already shown in [6] , but our approach is simpler and emphasizes the combinatorial aspect. In [6] one can also find a proof of the next result, for which we follow a more direct method.
Let
be the standard basis of
Here we assume that the indices
are arranged in the ascending lexicographic order.
Lemma 1
The origin is the only singular point of
.
Proof .-We prove the claim using the Jacobian criterion. Let
| |
| |
and let
be a Jacobian matrix associated with the set
of generators, evaluated at
. Its rows are
where
. Clearly
is the zero matrix, so that
is a singular point for
. Now suppose that
. Up to a change of indices we may assume that
. We prove that rank
. Set
for all
These are
elements of
. Let
be the
-submatrix of
formed by the entries
The rows of
are
where the second summand is missing whenever
.
Otherwise
is lexicographically smaller than
. Hence
is a lower triangular matrix whose diagonal entries are all equal to
. Thus
is invertible. It follows that rank
, and
is not a singular point for
. This completes the proof.
The following result contains the notion of Galois covering: we refer to [8] , p. 43 for a definition.
Lemma 2
Suppose that char
. The map
is a finite Galois covering with cyclic Galois group of order
.
Proof .-We show that
is an étale finite surjective map and that the multiplicative group
of the complex
-th roots of unity acts transitively and faithfully on every fiber of
. Surjectivity and finiteness are clear. The coordinate ring of
is
, and the coordinate ring of
is
Set
for all
. Then the Jacobian matrix
is the identity matrix of order
. According to [8] , Corollary 3.16, p. 27, this implies that
is étale.
Let
. Up to a permutation of indices we may assume that
and
, for some
,
. Let
.
Then for all
,
, where, for all
,
. We are going to show that
|
(2)
|
Let
. First assume that
, and
. In this case
for all
. Equating the entries of
and
of index
we have
from which we deduce that
and this implies ( 2 ). Now suppose that
and
. Equating the entries of
and
of index
we get
, whence
|
(3)
|
and equating their entries of index
we get, similarly,
|
(4)
|
If we divide ( 3 ) by ( 4 ) we obtain
, which implies ( 2 ). Finally suppose that
is odd. Equating the entries of
and
of index
we deduce that
|
(5)
|
and equating their entries of index
we get
|
(6)
|
From ( 5 ) and ( 6 ) we again deduce ( 2 ). It follows that, in all cases
This shows that
The opposite inclusion is obvious. This completes the proof.
2 The set-theoretic complete intersection property
In this section we show that
is a set-theoretic complete intersection (i.e., it is set-theoretically defined by
equations) if and only if char
.
We shall consider the subsemigroup
of
and the subgroup
of
generated by
. We need to recall the following two definitions, both quoted from [3] , pp. 1894–1895.
Definition 1
Let
be a prime number and let
and
be non-empty subsets of
such that
and
. Then
is called a p-gluing of
and
if there is
and a nonzero element
such that
and
.
Definition 2
An affine semigroup
is called completely
-glued if
is the
-gluing of
and
, where each of the semigroups
is completely
-glued or a free abelian semigroup.
There is a large class of completely
-glued semigroups:
Lemma 3
Let
be a prime number,
a positive integer, and let
If
, where
is finite, then the semigroup
is completely
-glued.
Proof .-We proceed by induction on
. Since
is free, for
there is nothing to prove. Suppose
and the claim true for all smaller
. Pick any
and set
,
.
Then, being
,
is completely
-glued by induction and, moreover,
, so that
. Hence
is the
-gluing of
ad
. This proves that
is completely
-glued.
In the same paper (see [3] , Theorem 5) we find the following characterization of set-theoretic complete intersections:
Theorem 2
Suppose that char
. Then a toric variety in over
is a set-theoretic complete intersection on binomials if and only if the associated semigroup is completely
-glued.
We shall also need the following criterion, cited from [4] , Lemma 3
.
Lemma 4
Let
be affine varieties. Let
. If there are
equations
such that
, then
and for all
which are prime to char
.
Finally we recall one result from group cohomology.
Lemma 5
Let
be a prime, and
be a positive integer. Let
be a cyclic group of order
. Then
with respect to any
-action on
.
Proof .-We consider
as a multiplicative group. Let
be a generator of
, and let
, where
and [] denotes the residue class mod
. Then the action of
on
is multiplication by
. Moreover,
, so that
.
Hence
(mod
). By Fermat's Little Theorem it follows that
(mod
). Consequently,
(mod
). Thus
This shows that
, the submodule of
-invariants of
. Now, by definition of group cohomology,
, so that
By a well-known property (see, e.g., [11] , Proposition 3-2-3), all cohomology groups of a cyclic group with respect to a finite
-module
have the same order.
This completes the proof.
We are now ready to prove:
Theorem 3
is a set-theoretic complete intersection if and only if char
.
Proof .-Let
be the subset of
associated with
. Then
is completely
-glued by virtue of Lemma 3 . By Theorem 2 it follows that, if char
,
is a set-theoretic complete intersection. Now suppose that char
. According to [8] , Theorem 2.20, p. 105, the map
in Lemma 2 gives rise to the following Hochschild-Serre spectral sequence:
where
and
denote group cohomology and étale cohomology respectively.
Recall that
|
(7)
|
and that, according to Lemma 5 ,
|
(8)
|
Since
, ( 7 ) and ( 8 ) imply that
|
(9)
|
Since, by Lemma 1 ,
is a smooth
-dimensional variety, we can apply Poincaré Duality to it (see [8] , Theorem 1.11, p. 276), so that
|
(10)
|
where
denotes cohomology with compact support. In the sequel we shall omit the coefficient group
for the sake of simplicity. From ( 9 ) and ( 10 ) we conclude that
|
(11)
|
We have a long exact sequence of cohomology with compact support
where, being
,
. Hence
so that, by ( 11 ),
|
(12)
|
We also have a long exact sequence
where
, so that
, and thus, in view of ( 12 ),
If we apply Poincaré Duality, we finally obtain
By Lemma 4 it follows that, under our present assumption that char
,
is not set-theoretically defined by
equations, i.e. it is not a set-theoretic complete intersection. This completes the proof.
According to the methods developed in [3] ,
is, in characteristic
, a set-theoretic complete intersection on the following set of
binomials
The same set of
binomials was found by Gattazzo [5] by direct computations.
Remark 2
The variety
(of codimension
) is the determinantal variety defined by the vanishing of the 2-minors of an
symmetric variety of indeterminates over
. Theorem 2 generalizes part of the results in [
1]
: there it was shown that the minimum number of equations required to define
set-theoretically is
which means that, for
,
is a set-theoretic complete intersection if and only if char
.
Remark 3
A general lower bound for the minimum number of equations which define a variety set-theoretically (the so-called arithmetical rank, ara) is given by the local cohomological dimension: if
, this number is
where
denotes local cohomology with respect to
. In the case of the Veronese variety
, the ideal
is perfect (see [
6]
, p. 259), so that, according to [
9]
, Prop. 4.1,
However, it follows from Theorem 3 that
so that the lower bound for the arithmetical rank provided by the local cohomological dimension is almost always non-sharp. Varieties where the local cohomological dimension and the arithmetical rank differ are particularly sought. The only previously known examples are the Pfaffian ideals of an alternating matrix of indeterminates, in all positive characteristics (see [
1]
, Remarks 6.2), and Reisner's variety, in all characteristics different from 2 (see [
10]
, p. 250, [
7]
, Example 1, and [
12]
, Example 2).
References
-
Barile, M.: Arithmetical ranks of ideals associated to symmetric and alternating matrices. J. Algebra, 176, 59–82 (1995)
-
Barile, M., Lyubeznik, G.: Set-theoretic complete intersections in characteristic
. Preprint (2004). To appear in: Proceedings of the American Mathematical Society.
-
Barile, M., Morales, M., Thoma, A.: Set-Theoretic Complete Intersections on Binomials. Proc. Amer. Soc., 130, 1893–1903 (2002)
-
Bruns, W., Schwänzl: The number of equations defining a determinantal variety. Bull. London Math. Soc., 22, 439–445 (1990)
-
Gattazzo, R.: In characteristic
the Veronese variety
and each of its generic projection is set-theoretic complete intersection, in: Greco, S., Strano, R. (eds.), Complete Intersections, Acireale 1983, Lecture Notes in Mathematics 1092, 221–228, Springer, Berlin-Heidelberg (1984)
-
Gröbner, W.: Über Veronesesche Varietäten und deren Projektionen. Arch. Math., 16, 257–264 (1965)
-
Lyubeznik, G.: On the local cohomology modules
for ideals
generated by monomials in an
-sequence, in: Greco, S., Strano, R. (eds.), Complete Intersections, Acireale 1983, Lecture Notes in Mathematics 1092, 221–228, Springer, Berlin-Heidelberg (1984)
-
Milne, J.: Étale Cohomology. Princeton University Press, Princeton (1980)
-
Peskine, C., Szpiro, L.: Dimension finie et cohomologie locale. Inst. Hautes Études Sci. Publ. Math. 42, 47–119 (1973)
-
Schmitt, Th., Vogel, W.: Note on Set-Theoretic Intersections of Subvarieties of Projective Space. Math. Ann. 245, 247–253 (1979)
-
Weiss, E.: Cohomology of Groups. Academic Press, New York, London (1969)
-
Yan, Z.: An étale analog of the Goresky-MacPherson formula for subspace arrangements. J. Pure Appl. Algebra 146, 305–318 (2000)